Showing posts with label benedict samuel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label benedict samuel. Show all posts

Tuesday, 3 April 2012

Pash, Pick or Pass: Marchetta's Men


That's right, Pash, Pick or Pass is back! And it's a doozy...


The contenders

-Jonah Griggs from On the Jellicoe Road by Melina Marchetta, a fiercesome army cadet with a damaged past and a tender heart (le sigh). Played in my head by Liam Hemsworth.



-Tom Mackee from Saving Francesca and The Piper's Son by Melina Marchetta. He's a blokey boy who can proudly burp the alphabet, but he also has a sensitive side (hello, muso). Played in my head by Benedict Samuel.


-Jacob Coote from Looking For Alibrandi by Melina Marchetta. Another rough-around-the-edges-but-deep-down-really-sweet guy (they seem to be a MM speciality!), he's a walking contradiction. A totally swoon-worthy one. Played by Kick Gurry in the movie.


My choices

Pash: Jonah. I love his passion. And his hotness. But he's one of those characters that is so obviously meant for another (Taylor) I just couldn't interfere. Much.


Pick: Tom. Maybe it was being in his head for half of The Piper's Son, but I feel more connected to him than the others. Once he gets his shit together I reckon he'd make a pretty decent pick.


Pass: Sorry, Jacob, you were my first MM love, and I'll always have a special place in my heart for you but... you've been eclipsed.

Come on MM fans, you know you want to play! Who would you pash, pick and pass?

Tuesday, 31 January 2012

Review: The Piper's Son by Melina Marchetta

This book was painful. Like, I-feel-like-my-heart-is-bleeding kinda painful. A good kinda painful, then. Naturally. 



The Pipers Son is the sequel/companion to Melina Marchettas Saving Francesca, and it picks up the characters lives five years down the track. This time, Tom Mackee is our main character, along with his aunt Georgie, as the book alternates between their viewpoints via third person narration. They, along with the rest of their family and friends, are trying to recover from some devastating losses in the past (both recent and distant). 

With protagonists that are 22 and 42, The Pipers Son feels a bit more grown up than Saving Francesca and Looking for Alibrandi, and the third person narrative also sets it apart. The writing is even more beautiful, if thats at all possible. I liked being able to get into more than one characters head, as well as seeing them from the outside. It gave the story a much wider scope than it perhaps would have had otherwise.

Now, I thought Saving Francesca was sad, but I have to say, its got nothing on The Pipers Son. Tom and Georgie are both so lost in their grief and its such an emotional ride, made all the more potent by the extremely realistic characters, conversations, emotions and actions. As with Marchettas other books that Ive read, I found myself nodding along to a characters inner monologue more than once. I really felt their pain. And it was tough.

Thankfully, there are plenty of light moments to balance out the sadness. As Tom slowly reconnects with the old gang from St Sebastians, the friendly teasing comes back into play and you cant help but smile. The interactions between the Mackee family are also tinged with humour, and theres a lot of joy mixed in with their hurt. The best moments, though, come from Tara (who is in Timor) and Toms email exchanges. Though they're half a world apart (literally and emotionally), their spark is still there, waiting to be set alight. I just love all of these characters; theyre strong, unique, and well fleshed-out. I feel like I know them well if only I had friends like these in real life!

Rating: 4/5

Spoilery Talking Points
  • I was sad at the lack of Jimmy in this book. He was one of my favourite characters in Saving Francesca. I need to know that he's OK.
  • On the other hand, the suggestion that Frankie's parents are doing great is heartening. 
  • I also kinda missed Siobhan! She seemed to be doing well though. I was kinda glad they were all still friends. Well, except for the whole Tom kerfuffle - but he made good in the end.
  • On an entirely superficial note, I really want to know what Will's tatt looks like.

Eye Candy
The same as Saving Francesca, plus...

Benedict Samuel as Tom

Claudia Karvan as Georgie

Emily Browning as Tara

Guy Pearce as Sam
Fine Print
Genre: Contemporary fiction
Published: March 2010, Viking
Get It: Fishpond